Welcome to The Pizzeria of Bayport
At The Pizzeria of Bayport, we blend tradition with a contemporary touch, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere where food lovers unite. Nestled in Bayport, NY, our story revolves around crafting authentic Italian pizza and sandwiches that spark joy with every bite. Our signature pies, like the Bayport Pie and Vodka Margherita, showcase high-quality ingredients and passion for culinary excellence. Whether you’re enjoying a cozy dinner or grabbing takeout, our menu is designed to cater to all, complemented by a selection of beer and wine. Join us for a delightful experience in a community-driven setting, where every meal is made with love.
The Pizzeria of Bayport: Reviews & Ratings
This is an edited review Wow. My original review was pure dissatisfaction. The pizza was a 25 and I was being generous in that review because the atmosphere was nice and so were the people. The owner assured me that this was a oneoff ...
I just love love LOVE the pizzeria. Every time I go there I not only have a great time, I also eat delicious food. They have a great selection to choose from. Also the manager Brando is very nice
My family gets food from this location at least once every week and all of the staff are always so welcoming and nice. It is so heartwarming to see the effort and positivity that they put into the atmosphere at the Pizzeria. This is my ...
Best pizzeria in Suffolk County! Pizza slices are delish and so are their pastas! Cant beat their BOGO pasta deal on Wednesdays. Everyone is super friendly and helpful, shout out to Dan and Brandon ...
Overall, great place. Come here for lunch 34 times a week and never leave with a complaint. Great service and atmosphere. Employees are all really nice and I personally love the buffalo chicken slice. Would definitely recommend.
Michael makes the best pizza on the island. Cant recommend this place enough. No wonder its always packed in here. Brando your amazing service is the best. Bravo! Ill be back!!
A must if you want great pizza friendly staff! They treated us tourists as family! Definitely going back with the 3 days we have left. Ask for their recommended pie slices. You cant go wrong.
The pizza was delicious! Brando was so helpful in picking out slices and helping me and my friends out. I even let him ride my scooter. The girls were sweet and attentive as well, thank you guys!
Location
-
606 Montauk Hwy Bayport, NY 11705 Hotline: (631) 472-5959
Welcome to The Pizzeria of Bayport, a delightful gem tucked away at 606 Montauk Hwy in Bayport, NY. This charming establishment specializes in authentic Italian cuisine, serving up a mouthwatering variety of pizzas, sandwiches, and delectable starters. Whether you're a local seeking your next favorite slice or a visitor wanting to indulge in the area's culinary scene, The Pizzeria of Bayport has something special to offer.
As you step inside, you're greeted by a warm atmosphere, complete with both indoor and heated outdoor seating options. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a meal here. For those who prefer dining al fresco, the covered outdoor seating provides a perfect spot to savor your meal while enjoying the fresh air.
The menu is a feast for the senses. With large pies starting at just $21.95 and unique creations like the Bayport Pie with its sweet red sauce and fresh mozzarella, your taste buds are in for a treat. Other highlights include the Vodka Margarita Pie and the flavor-packed TriFecta Pie—each a testament to the pizzeria's commitment to quality ingredients and innovative flavor combinations.
- Starters: No visit is complete without their famous Garlic Knots—a must-try at only $0.60 each!
- Slice Selection: Choose from an array of generous slices, such as the Buffalo Chicken Slice and mouthwatering Detroit Slice, each priced at just $5.57.
In addition to pizza, The Pizzeria of Bayport offers an array of sandwiches and catering options, making it a perfect choice for any gathering. Plus, with free Wi-Fi available on-site, you can work or browse while enjoying your meal.
With a wide selection of beer and wine to complement your meal, plus plenty of TV screens to catch the latest game, The Pizzeria of Bayport is more than just a place to eat—it's a community hub. Call (631) 472-5959 for delivery or takeout, and get ready to savor the flavors of Bayport!
For anyone who appreciates quality pizza surrounded by a welcoming atmosphere, The Pizzeria of Bayport truly stands out as a culinary destination worth visiting again and again.
